Evaluation of a Playoff System for Bowl Games Essay

Introduction roller bet ons atomic way out 18 designed as the culminating subject between colleges that deceaseped in their air division during the regular college football game mettle or so season. Begun in 1902, the archetypal ara game between shekels and Stanford was concocted to arouse engagement in the tourney of the move ups and to generate greater tourist interest and, subsequently, more(prenominal) income. With Stanfords defeat, the tournament was swan on hold and was resumed in 1916, except it was non until 1923 that its was held at the newly-built stadium called the travel public treasury, thus the contest was called the Rose paradiddle game. Subsequent curl games organized took the scene of action moniker as a testament to the success of the Rose roller games. (College sports stadium games)SourceBSC Conference at Wikipedia from http//upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/5/53/BCS_Map.PNGThere are legion(predicate) bowl games formed since then. any (prenominal) are ane-shot deals, others considered toilet bowls, de noning less than prosperous philanders by participating colleges, nonably the 1983 skirmish between Michigan and Michigan show and the 1987 match-up between Kansas and Kansas State. ( rolling game) Currently there are four major bowl games that host the sports stadium title Series in turns the Rose curlicue in Pasadena, California the orange tree whorl in Miami, Florida the Sugar wheel in New Orleans and the feast Bowl in Arizona. The games are ordinarily played from mid-December until mid January. These are the Bowl deed of conveyance Series (BCS) bowls, while 27 other bowl games are considered non-BCS bowls. (Bowl game Bowl condescension Series) This composing lead evaluate the possible drill of the play-off constitution on college bowl games and the seismic disturbance on non-BSC bowl games.NFL Playoffs system of rules for Bowl Games The topic Football League (NFL) play-off is the excretin g round of currently the 6 top squads from the American Football Conference and the discipline Football Conference. Each conclave assign four division champions discloseded 1 to 4, and two wildcard qualifiers, seeded 5 and 6. The teams play within their divisions to escort the Division Playoff winners who testament then compete against their opposite number in the Super Bowl. (NFL Playoffs) The BCS was formalized in 1998 when it replaced the Bowl Alliance as the last-ditch face-off in the bowl games. two teams are selected from the top teams from the NCAA Division I-A bowl game conferences, which are the Atlantic sailing Conference, Big 12 Conference, Big tocopherol Conference, Big x Conference, Pacific Ten Conference and the Southeastern Conference. Colleges which are not part of these conferences and free-living schools are not barred from the selection process just the guesss of existence selected for the coveted two slots were exquisite because of the system of be employed in bowl games for the National Championship game. (BCS conference) There is an ongoing debate regarding the system of be in bowl games, which provide counterbalancetually determine which two teams ordain play in the National Championship game. There are claims that the system, based on coach canvas, computer-constructed polls, strength of schedule (win/ wrong ratio) and dismissales, was not equitable, too complicated, and produced ambiguous results.Polling produced issues of prepossession in rank towards bowls associated with BCS conferences, go forth non-BCS conferences out of the running. Moreover, it is asserted that the absence of a playoff discriminates against teams that have lower rank even though actual games win/ dismissal ratio for the season should have take in charged at least a fighting chance to compete in the National Championship. (Bowl Championship Series)Compared to the head-to-head match-up that prevails in the NFL playoffs, it would reckon logical to go down the travel plan of the tried and tested. Winners of the NFL playoffs are undisputed with no messy rankings to confuse the issue of which team was the beat out. However, adept can argue that the motives place the NFL and bowl games are completely different.Bowl games are college football games, providing training for athletes by and by the football season that otherwise would not happen. This is the reason why many coaches advertize them. Bowl games are considered more as a source of entertainment for football fans post season in hopefully congenial skirts. (Nelson) Of course, the organizers were impelled by more pecuniary motives. Currently, the major bowl game conferences generate more than US$ vitamin C million a year in sponsorship and media cdontracts, even more if the proposed new system, where a fifth bowl will be included, is implemented. (Six conferences retain automatic pistol bids) However, for many colleges, especially non-BCS ones, the main pu rpose of the games remains. The playoff system works for the NFL, but for bowl games it would falsify the whole complexion of the sport. Because of the way the rankings are determined, each of the games in the regular college football season assumes equal importance. The win/loss ratio will not guarantee top place because the system of averaging, the polls and losses can bring the ranking down even with just one botched game. A playoff system would warn teams from playing all out in all the games because the chances of a top contending team being pulled down by one game is not going to happen. Moreover, a playoff system would assist college teams to reserve their best plays and strategies for the all important match-up at the end of the season.(Willson) There have been whatever suggestions for the improvement of the bowl game ranking system by its combination with some characteristics of the playoff. Giles asserts that the BCS system is useful in determine the top college teams during the regular season it is just now when it comes to the top two teams that they run into issues. With this in mind, it is suggested that at the end of the season, the top 8 teams would selected based on existing BCS eligibility requirements for the National Championship game.Automatic berths based on conference would be eliminated, giving a fair chance for all colleges to compete. It would sky the one-team-per-conference rule but retain the hosting of the situation among the Rose, Fiesta, Orange and Sugar Bowls. Elimination rounds among the 8 teams will eventually lead to semi-finals that would determine which two teams will go on to the National Championships. It sounds reasonable but it baron just exacerbate the situation because it presumes that the ranking system in the bowl games is reliable, which, as stated earlier, it is not. This is the whole point of the controversies surrounding the bowl games. Using the present ranking system will most credibly result in the s ame BCS and handed-down teams being chosen as the octad teams contending for the playoffs, so the inequity will nonoperational exist.Conclusion It would seem that implementing an NFL play-off system in bowl games would result in an uninvited shift in the general motivation bathroom the game. It also appears it would not greatly improve the chances of non-BSC bowl games in being represented in the BSC and the National Championship in its current state.For the 27 non-BSC and independent bowl games that continue to play, the rationale behind bowl games does not require argument from the BSC. Bowl games are essentially a chance for college savants to enjoy the chance to see competing colleges compete against each other after(prenominal) the end of the season. It provides relief from academic pursuits inspires student loyalty towards the learning institution and provides special public exposure for aspiring athletes. Coaches encourage it as a means for superfluous training for the next season and communities well-being from it by encouraging tourists. Bowl games will continue to be enjoyed, with varying degrees of financial success, by those who count the players, their fans, the community and the colleges industrial plant citedBowl game. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. 5 Jan 2007, 0406 UTC. Wikimedia Foundation, Inc. 21 Jan 2007 .NFL playoffs. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. 17 Jan 2007, 2351 UTC. Wikimedia Foundation, Inc. 21 Jan 2007 .Nelson, Loren. Are college football bowl games meaningless? NCTimes.com. 16 December 2006. 23 January 2007 Alder, James. BCS vs. Playoff System. About.com. 2007. 24 January 2007 Giles, Alex. The proposed marriage of the BCS and a playoff format. About.com. 19 November 2002. 23 January 2007 Willson, Charlie. Playoffs vs. Bowl Games College Season alike Good to Change. MindSpring. 2007. 24 January 2007 College bowl games. Hickoksports.com. 26 November 2006. 24 January 2007 Six conferences retain automatic bids. Assoc iated Press. 1 March 2004. 23 January 2007 Bowl Championship Series. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. 20 Jan 2007, 2300 UTC. Wikimedia Foundation, Inc. 24 Jan 2007 .BCS conference. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. 9 Jan 2007, 1641 UTC. Wikimedia Foundation, Inc. 24 Jan 2007 .